Dealing desk
Also called market maker model, B-book
A desk where a firm's traders deal for its own account. A retail FX or CFD provider with one takes the other side of client trades and keeps some or all of the risk, which can conflict with clients' interests.

- Level
- Intermediate
- Reading
- 2 min
- Sources
- 5ExchangeRegulatorRegulation
- Updated
On this page· 6 sections
When a client buys from a retail forex or CFD provider, someone sells to the client. Usually that is the provider itself, trading as principal[5], and “dealing desk” is one name for that arrangement.
In a bank the same words name something else. Nasdaq’s glossary defines a dealing desk, also called a trading desk, as the personnel at an international bank who trade spot and forward foreign exchange[1]. The two meanings share only the phrase.
How it works
Retail CFD products trade over the counter, and the firm typically takes the other side of the client’s trade[5]. Some firms hedge with external liquidity providers, trade by trade or within an agreed risk appetite, while others keep the full market risk against the client’s position[5]. Some trade as matched principal and cannot fill a client order without a matching hedge[5].
ASIC’s 2018 review of 57 retail derivative issuers ranked the approaches by popularity. Hedging all market risk with another party came first, hedging part and holding the rest second, and holding all market risk on the issuer’s own books third[2].
The conflict sits in the unhedged part. ESMA’s 2018 decision on CFDs notes that providers that are counterparties to client trades without hedging have interests in direct conflict with their clients[3]. For them, it says, there is a greater risk and incentive to use less transparent reference prices, to cancel profitable trades on spurious pretexts, or to exploit asymmetric slippage: passing slippage losses to the client while keeping slippage gains[3]. The FCA made the same point about leverage, since a firm that does not hedge benefits directly from client losses[5].
Example
Say a provider’s clients are long 20 lots of a currency pair in total, a pip on 1 lot is worth $10, and the pair falls 50 pips.
- Clients lose 50 × $10 × 20 = $10,000.
- A provider that held all of that risk on its own book gains the same $10,000.
- A provider that offset all 20 lots with another party loses $10,000 on the offset and keeps its charges, for example a 1-pip mark-up on entry: 20 × $10 = $200.
- Had the pair risen 50 pips instead, the first provider would pay its clients’ $10,000 gain out of its own book, and the second would still keep $200.
The second provider earns the same either way. The first earns when its clients lose.
Watch out
Hedging moves risk rather than removing it. Passing market risk to another party adds counterparty risk, and about a third of the issuers ASIC reviewed relied on related parties for pricing and hedging, which concentrates that risk in one counterparty[2].
Prices are hard to check from outside. Retail off-exchange forex has no central marketplace, and because individual traders often lack pricing information, it can be difficult for them to tell whether an offered price is fair[4].
At TRONEXO
TRONEXO’s services are not brokerage or investment services. On the simulated Challenge accounts and TRONEXO Accounts, no order is sent to a real exchange, broker or market, and no trading in real financial instruments takes place. See the FAQ.
Sources
- ExchangeNasdaqDealing desk (Trading desk) DefinitionChecked November 9, 2026
- RegulatorAustralian Securities and Investments CommissionReport 579: Improving practices in the retail OTC derivatives sector (June 2018)Checked November 9, 2026
- RegulationEuropean Securities and Markets Authority (EUR-Lex)ESMA Decision (EU) 2018/796 temporarily restricting CFDs to retail clientsChecked November 9, 2026
- RegulatorU.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Investor.gov)Foreign Currency Exchange (Forex) Trading For Individual InvestorsChecked November 9, 2026
- RegulatorFinancial Conduct AuthorityCP16/40: Enhancing conduct of business rules for firms providing contract for difference products to retail clientsChecked November 9, 2026
