Illusion of control
Believing that personal involvement can influence outcomes that are largely down to chance, for example feeling that choosing and placing one's own trades makes winning more likely.

- Level
- Intermediate
- Reading
- 2 min
- Sources
- 4ResearchProfessional body
- Updated
On this page· 5 sections
Picking your own lottery ticket does not change the odds. In Ellen Langer’s 1975 study, it changed what people thought the ticket was worth: those who chose their own ticket asked an average of $8.67 to sell it back, against $1.96 for those who had no choice[4].
Langer called this the illusion of control: personal involvement pushes the expected chance of success above what the odds justify[4].
How it works
Langer argued that the illusion appears when a game of chance carries features of a game of skill[4]. Barber and Odean list four such features from Langer’s work: choice, familiarity with the task, competition and active involvement[1]. A review of 53 experiments, which they cite, found illusion-of-control effects across many tasks and situations[1].
For online investors, Barber and Odean single out active involvement. These investors place orders themselves, without a broker on the phone, and may feel that doing so improves their chances[1]. Online brokerage ads stressed taking control, and in a survey of 832 visitors to an online broker’s website, “feeling of empowerment” was among seven reasons given for switching to online trading[1].
Mark Fenton-O’Creevy and colleagues measured the illusion directly in professionals. They argue that the task and environment of trading encourage illusions of control[3]. Using a computer task with 107 traders in four organizations, they found that traders more prone to the illusion performed worse, both in their managers’ ratings and in total pay[3]. Their conclusion: at least in that setting, the illusion is maladaptive[3].
Example
Say a method wins 45% of its trades, whoever places them. The trader believes that watching every tick and clicking by hand lifts that to 55%, and so doubles the risk per trade from $100 to $200.
- The real chance of a loss is still 55%. The chance of five losses in a row from a given trade is 0.55⁵, about 5%.
- At $100 a trade, such a run costs $500.
- At $200 a trade, it costs $1,000, or 10% of a $10,000 account.
The belief did not change the odds. It changed the size, and with it how much a normal bad run takes out of the account.
Watch out
It is a thinking error, and those can be worked on. CFA Institute’s curriculum classes the illusion of control as a belief perseverance bias, a cognitive error, and notes that cognitive errors are easier to correct than emotional biases[2].
A sense of control is not the same as better results. In the study of 107 traders, more illusion went with lower pay and weaker ratings[3].
The illusion can come with the setup. Barber and Odean argue that online trading, with its information, self-management and one-click orders, fosters greater overconfidence[1].
Sources
- ResearchTerrance Odean, UC Berkeley Haas (author copy)Online Investors: Do the Slow Die First? (Barber & Odean, Review of Financial Studies 15(2), 2002)Checked November 9, 2026
- Professional bodyCFA InstituteThe Behavioral Biases of Individuals (2026 Level I refresher reading)Checked November 9, 2026
- ResearchLSE Research Online (abstract record)Trading on illusions: unrealistic perceptions of control and trading performance (Fenton-O'Creevy, Nicholson, Soane & Willman, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 76(1), 2003)Checked November 9, 2026
- ResearchPubMed Central, U.S. National Library of MedicineLet me take the wheel: Illusory control and sense of agency (Tobias-Webb et al., Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 70(8), 2017)Checked November 9, 2026
