New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Illusion of control

Believing that personal involvement can influence outcomes that are largely down to chance, for example feeling that choosing and placing one's own trades makes winning more likely.

Reading
2 min
Sources
4ResearchProfessional body
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

Picking your own lottery ticket does not change the odds. In Ellen Langer’s 1975 study, it changed what people thought the ticket was worth: those who chose their own ticket asked an average of $8.67 to sell it back, against $1.96 for those who had no choice[4].

Langer called this the illusion of control: personal involvement pushes the expected chance of success above what the odds justify[4].

How it works

Langer argued that the illusion appears when a game of chance carries features of a game of skill[4]. Barber and Odean list four such features from Langer’s work: choice, familiarity with the task, competition and active involvement[1]. A review of 53 experiments, which they cite, found illusion-of-control effects across many tasks and situations[1].

For online investors, Barber and Odean single out active involvement. These investors place orders themselves, without a broker on the phone, and may feel that doing so improves their chances[1]. Online brokerage ads stressed taking control, and in a survey of 832 visitors to an online broker’s website, “feeling of empowerment” was among seven reasons given for switching to online trading[1].

Mark Fenton-O’Creevy and colleagues measured the illusion directly in professionals. They argue that the task and environment of trading encourage illusions of control[3]. Using a computer task with 107 traders in four organizations, they found that traders more prone to the illusion performed worse, both in their managers’ ratings and in total pay[3]. Their conclusion: at least in that setting, the illusion is maladaptive[3].

Example

Say a method wins 45% of its trades, whoever places them. The trader believes that watching every tick and clicking by hand lifts that to 55%, and so doubles the risk per trade from $100 to $200.

  1. The real chance of a loss is still 55%. The chance of five losses in a row from a given trade is 0.55⁵, about 5%.
  2. At $100 a trade, such a run costs $500.
  3. At $200 a trade, it costs $1,000, or 10% of a $10,000 account.

The belief did not change the odds. It changed the size, and with it how much a normal bad run takes out of the account.

Watch out

It is a thinking error, and those can be worked on. CFA Institute’s curriculum classes the illusion of control as a belief perseverance bias, a cognitive error, and notes that cognitive errors are easier to correct than emotional biases[2].

A sense of control is not the same as better results. In the study of 107 traders, more illusion went with lower pay and weaker ratings[3].

The illusion can come with the setup. Barber and Odean argue that online trading, with its information, self-management and one-click orders, fosters greater overconfidence[1].

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10