New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Hindsight bias

Also called knew-it-all-along effect

The tendency, once an outcome is known, to believe it was more predictable than it was. It can make people overconfident about their ability to predict.

Reading
2 min
Sources
4RegulatorProfessional bodyResearch
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

After the close, the chart explains itself. The breakout had a reason, the reversal had a warning sign, and both look like things anyone could have seen coming.

Baruch Fischhoff called this “creeping determinism” in 1975: the tendency to see a reported outcome as having been relatively inevitable[4]. The FCA and CFA Institute call it hindsight bias[1][3].

How it works

Fischhoff’s first experiment gave students a 150-word account of a historical or clinical event with four possible outcomes[4]. One group read it with no outcome. Four other groups each read the same text with one outcome added as the one that had happened, so three of the four were told something false[4]. Everyone then rated how likely each outcome had been[4].

One account was the British campaign against the Gurkhas of Nepal that began in November 1814[4]. Among English-speaking students, 20 per group:

  • the group told nothing rated a British victory 33.8% likely;
  • the group told the British had won rated it 57.2% likely.

The pattern held everywhere. In all 24 comparisons, across six subexperiments using four events, being told an outcome raised its judged probability. The increases ran from 3.6 to 23.4 percentage points, with a mean of 10.8[4].

The second finding matters more for learning. The judges were largely unaware of the effect, so they overestimated what they would have known without the outcome, and what others who lacked it did know[4].

A Financial Conduct Authority paper links hindsight to overconfidence: because any past event can be explained afterward, people grow overconfident about predicting future ones[1]. A 2010 report prepared for the SEC, summing up work by Kahneman and Mark Riepe, lists hindsight among the biases of judgment that lead to poor investment decisions[2]. CFA Institute’s curriculum classes it as a belief perseverance bias, a type of cognitive error[3].

Example

Say a trader writes a note before a central bank meeting: 40% chance of a rate hike, 60% chance of no change. The bank hikes, and the trader’s position loses.

  1. A week later, memory says: “I was fairly sure of a hike, maybe 70%.”
  2. The note says 40%.
  3. The gap, 30 points, is larger than Fischhoff’s average shift but in the same direction: toward the outcome that happened.

Read from memory, the lesson is “I knew and did not act”. Read from the note, it is “a 40% outcome happened”. Those lead to different changes in a method.

Watch out

Knowing about the bias is not enough. Fischhoff’s judges could not tell how much the outcome had changed their view, and Fischhoff argued that this lack of awareness can seriously restrict the ability to judge or learn from the past[4].

A false report works as well as a true one. The effect held whether or not the reported outcome had in fact happened[4].

An explanation after the fact is not a forecast. The ease of explaining past events is what the FCA links to overconfidence about future ones[1].

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10