New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Outcome bias

Also called resulting

Judging a decision by its result rather than by the reasoning and information available when it was made, so a lucky win looks like a good trade and a sound loss like a bad one.

Reading
2 min
Sources
2ResearchRegulator
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

A trade that made money feels like a good trade, and one that lost feels like a mistake. Yet information that arrives only after a decision is irrelevant to how good the decision was[1].

The result is real, and so is the money. What it cannot do on its own is say whether the reasoning behind the trade was sound.

How it works

Jonathan Baron and John Hershey sort the information around a decision into three kinds. Actor information was known only to the decision maker at the time. Judge information is known only to whoever evaluates it later, and the outcome is of that kind. Joint information was known to both[1].

Their 1988 paper tested how much the outcome sways the judge. In one study, 40 undergraduates rated decisions about simple money gambles on a scale from −30 to +30[1]. They were told that chance came from a fair roulette wheel and that the decision maker knew nothing more than they did[1].

One decision was a choice between $200 for sure and an 80% chance of $300[1]:

  • When the decision maker took the gamble and won $300, the average rating was +7.5[1].
  • When the same choice paid nothing, it was −6.5[1].

The gamble’s expected value, $240, was higher than the sure $200 in both cases. Only the luck differed.

Even outcomes that never happened counted. A decision to take the sure $200 was rated 15.1 when the gamble would have paid nothing, and 9.3 when it would have paid $300[1]. The authors suggest that an outcome draws attention to the arguments on one side, as a death on the operating table draws attention to the risk of surgery[1].

Example

Say two traders take the same setup under the same plan: risk $100 to make $200, on a setup that wins 40% of the time.

  1. Expected result per trade: 0.4 × $200 − 0.6 × $100 = +$20.
  2. Trader A’s trade reaches the target: +$200.
  3. Trader B’s trade hits the stop: −$100.

Judged by result, A decided well and B badly. Judged by the decision, they made the same one, worth +$20 each on average. Over 50 such trades, that is +$1,000 expected, and both A’s and B’s results are part of it.

Watch out

Outcomes are not useless. When a judge has nothing but the outcome, Baron and Hershey consider it a reasonable first guess that a bad outcome came from a bad decision[1].

The trade not taken counts too. In their gambles, people judged a choice partly by what the rejected option would have paid[1].

A few wins are thin evidence. Among common errors, an FCA paper lists judging financial advice as good on the basis of a few successful investments, even though they could reflect pure luck[2].

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10