New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Internalization

Also called internalisation, in-house execution

When a broker fills a client order from its own inventory, or matches clients against each other in-house, instead of sending it to an exchange. Such trades are less visible to the wider market.

Reading
2 min
Sources
3RegulatorInternational body
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

Your broker may never send your order anywhere. It can fill the order itself, from securities it already holds, or match it against other clients’ orders. That is internalization.

SEC staff put it this way: a broker-dealer internalizes an order when it executes the order out of its own inventory instead of routing it to an exchange or other platform, or matches buyers and sellers together outside an exchange or an alternative trading system[1].

How it works

The order stays inside the firm. The SEC’s investor site says a broker may send an order to another division of its own firm, to be filled from the firm’s inventory. The firm can then earn the spread: the difference between what it paid for the security and the price at which it sells to the customer[2].

In US stocks the practice is large. SEC staff calculated that about 27% of share volume in NMS stocks, which are in general those listed on a national securities exchange, was executed by broker-dealer internalizers in 2019, much of it by a small number of large firms[1]. Retail brokers largely route marketable retail orders, meaning orders that can be executed immediately, to internalizing broker-dealers known as wholesale market makers. Some of these brokers receive payment for order flow in exchange[1].

Retail orders can fare well. Wholesalers can frequently fill inside the national best bid and offer, which the staff calls price improvement. They can also trade in finer steps than the one-penny increment for quotes, because they do not post quotes[1].

The cost is visibility. Internalized trades reflect liquidity that is not in public quotation data[1]. In October 2020 the BIS Markets Committee reported that execution algorithms in the FX market also reinforce the trend toward internalization, which reduces the visibility of trades, can complicate the measurement of liquidity and, at the extreme, could negatively affect price discovery[3].

Example

Say a stock is quoted at $49.98 bid and $50.00 offer. You send a market order to buy 200 shares, and your broker passes it to a wholesaler that holds shares it bought earlier at $49.98.

  1. The wholesaler fills you at $49.995, half a cent inside the offer. You pay 200 × $49.995 = $9,999.00, against 200 × $50.00 = $10,000.00 at the offer: $1.00 less.
  2. The wholesaler sells at $49.995 shares that cost $49.98, so it earns 200 × $0.015 = $3.00 on the trade.

You paid less than the quoted offer, and the firm still earned the difference between its cost and its sale price.

Watch out

Internalization is not payment for order flow. The first describes who fills the order, the second a payment from a market maker to a broker for routing it[2].

The firm is on the other side of your trade, yet it still owes a duty of best execution, which includes weighing the opportunity for price improvement[2].

A wholesaler can choose what to fill. Because wholesale market makers may decide whether to execute any given order, they can trade against incoming retail orders or route relatively risky ones to exchanges or other market centers[1].

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10