New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Overtrading

Also called excessive trading

Trading more often than one's information and trading costs justify. Studies of retail brokerage accounts find the most active traders earn less, and link heavy trading to overconfidence.

Reading
2 min
Sources
4ResearchRegulator
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

Every trade has a cost before it has a result. Trade often enough and the costs can outweigh whether the ideas were any good.

There is no fixed number of trades that counts as overtrading. The test is whether the trades carry enough information to pay for themselves. In a large study of US retail brokerage accounts, the most active traders failed it.

How it works

Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied 66,465 households with accounts at a large US discount broker from 1991 to 1996[1]. The average household turned over 75% of its portfolio a year, and those that traded most turned over more than 250%[1].

Before costs, frequent and infrequent traders did about equally well. After costs, the households with monthly turnover above 8.8% earned 11.4% a year, while those that traded least earned 18.5%[1]. Over the same period the market returned 17.9%[1]. In their data, a round-trip trade cost on average about 1% in bid-ask spread and about 3% in commissions[1].

Barber and Odean argue that overconfidence explains the high trading levels and the poor results that follow[1]. A 2010 report prepared for the SEC sums up their finding: active traders underperform the market, and active trading correlates with overconfidence[2].

FINRA’s guidance on frequent intraday trading lists the same pressures today. Frequent trading can bring higher costs that erode returns, possible tax effects, and a need for continuous attention to the market[3]. FINRA adds that frequent trading on margin is generally not appropriate for people with limited financial resources, limited investment or trading experience, or low risk tolerance[3].

Example

Say a trader has a $10,000 account and pays $10 in commission and spread on every round trip.

  1. At 20 round trips a month, costs are 20 × $10 × 12 = $2,400 a year, or 24% of the account.
  2. At 4 round trips a month, costs are 4 × $10 × 12 = $480 a year, or 4.8%.

At the higher pace, the trades have to earn 24% a year before costs to leave the account where it started. The ideas behind the trades are the same in both cases. Only the count differs.

Watch out

Gross results can hide the problem. In Barber and Odean’s data the gap between active and inactive households came almost entirely from costs, not from worse stock picks[1].

Excessive trading that a broker recommends is a separate, regulated matter. FINRA’s suitability rule says no single test defines excessive activity, and looks at factors such as the turnover rate, the cost-equity ratio and in-and-out trading in the customer’s account[4].

Costs scale with the count, not the result. A losing trade and a winning one cost the same to make.

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10