New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Whipsaw

Also called whipsaw trade

A signal that is reversed soon after it appears, such as a moving-average cross up followed quickly by a cross down, typical of sideways markets. Each round trip tends to cost a small loss plus trading costs.

Reading
2 min
Sources
4ExchangeProfessional bodyReference
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

A buy signal on Monday, a sell signal on Wednesday. StockCharts calls this a whipsaw: a buy or sell signal reversed in a short time, often the result of volatile markets and sensitive indicators[3].

Its glossary gives an example. A position trader goes long on a bullish MACD crossover and has to close the position the next day because a bearish moving-average crossover appears[3]. Each indicator followed its own rule, and the signal was reversed within a day[3].

How it works

Trend tools assume a trend. Moving-average crossovers work well once a strong trend takes hold, but when there is no strong trend, a crossover system produces many whipsaws[4]. Because moving averages lag, each signal also comes after part of the move it reacts to[4].

The length of the average sets the trade-off. A longer average is smoother and gives fewer trades and fewer false signals, but enters and exits later. A shorter one gets in earlier, with more trades and more false signals[1].

One answer is a filter. StockCharts suggests a time filter, such as requiring a crossover to last three days, or a price filter, such as requiring the faster average to move a set distance past the slower one[4].

Practice differs from the textbook rule. The CFA Institute review notes that technical analysts generally combine several techniques rather than trade the simple rules that academic studies test[2].

Example

Say a share trades between $48 and $52 for three months, and a rule goes long when the close crosses above its 20-day average and exits when it crosses back below.

  1. The price crosses the average 8 times: 4 entries and 4 exits.
  2. Each entry follows a rise and each exit a fall. Say entries average $50.80 and exits $49.90: a loss of $0.90 per share per round trip.
  3. Add $0.10 per share in trading costs per round trip: $1.00 in all.
  4. On 500 shares: 4 × $1.00 × 500 = $2,000.

The share ended the period close to where it started. The $2,000 came from the rule’s timing, not from the market’s direction.

Now add a three-day filter, and suppose two of the four entries reversed within two days. Those two trades never happen, and the cost falls to 2 × $1.00 × 500 = $1,000. Every entry that does pass the filter comes three days later, in a range or in a real trend.

Watch out

A whipsaw is visible only in hindsight. At the moment of the signal, a crossover that will fail and one that starts a long trend look the same.

Filters move the cost rather than remove it. Fewer false signals come with later entries and exits[1][4].

Tuning a rule until it avoids past whipsaws invites data mining. The CFA Institute review describes testing every moving-average length to find the most profitable one, which is only the one that would have been most profitable over the period tested[2].

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10