The argument Waller made was not mostly about the latest inflation reading. It was about follow-through. The Fed told markets that more increases were coming, markets took that at face value, and in his telling a quarter point in December would leave that message only half-delivered.
Waller, a member of the Fed's Board of Governors, spoke in London on Tuesday, CNBC reported. He said he leans toward an increase next month even if October inflation lands softer than forecast, and that a half-point step should be on the table if the data comes in above it. A quarter point alone, he said, would put the central bank's credibility at risk.
Key numbers
- 50 basis points the size Waller said should be considered in December if October inflation runs above forecast, double the quarter point that is the Fed's usual increment
- Above 80% the probability of a quarter-point December increase implied by futures, with no chance given to a half point, according to CME Group's FedWatch as cited by CNBC
- 2% the inflation target Fed officials have kept pointing to since the October meeting
- December 8-9 the dates of the next policy meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee
The case rests on doing what was signaled
Waller's point was about sequence, not speed. The exact timing of each increase matters less, he said, than whether the increases that were communicated are actually carried out within a reasonable stretch of time. Moving at back-to-back meetings is not required for that.
The risk he described runs the other way. If the signaled increases never arrive, markets trim what they expect, and policy ends up looser than the committee intended.
In plain words: a central bank works through expectations as much as through its actual decisions. When officials point to higher rates ahead, borrowing costs across the market adjust before any vote is taken. If the central bank then delivers less than it indicated, that adjustment unwinds, and financial conditions turn easier than policymakers wanted.
October's meeting is what gives the remarks weight
The committee passed on an increase in October, saying more information would help it judge the right path for bringing inflation down. That decision split the room: Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack dissented.
Since then, according to CNBC, several officials have urged patience while repeating the 2% target. Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee said on Monday that the Fed has to avoid letting the economy run too hot, because overheating is extremely painful to undo once it sets in.
Waller's own read on conditions was not alarmed. He described growth at a healthy pace and a labor market that has been solid, in a climate of low hiring and low firing.
MarketWatch framed the same remarks as putting a half-point move into the mix, conditional on how hot the October consumer price data turns out to be. Neither of the reports I read gives a market reaction to what he said.
What to watch
- Tuesday, 10 November the Bureau of Labor Statistics releases the October consumer price index, one of the last inflation readings before the next policy meeting
- 8-9 December the Federal Open Market Committee's next policy meeting
