Healthcare was the other winner. The MSCI global healthcare index added 9.8% in October, which City A.M. describes as its second-best month this century, behind only the 12.4% it gained in April 2020, when the Covid pandemic began.
Staples and healthcare at the top, technology at the bottom: that is what a sector rotation looks like in the numbers. It describes money moving between parts of the market, not money leaving it.
Key numbers
- 10.6% gain in the MSCI consumer staples index in October, its best month in almost 30 years
- 9.8% gain in the MSCI global healthcare index in October, behind only April 2020's 12.4%
- 13% drop in the MSCI global technology index since October began
- 15% rise in Walmart shares since the Nasdaq Composite's 6 October high
Europe's lighter tech weighting showed up in the indexes
The Swiss Market Index, where drugmakers Roche and Novartis carry heavy weightings, rose 8.4% over the past month, according to City A.M.. Germany's DAX added 5.1% and the FTSE 100 1.5%. The Nasdaq Composite, with far more technology in it, did not share in the move.
Individual names followed the same pattern. Diageo gained 13% over the month, Reckitt Benckiser 8.1% and Unilever 4.1%, all three having been held back earlier by higher shipping and energy costs linked to the conflict in the Middle East. In the United States, Coca-Cola rose more than 10% and Walmart more than 15% from the Nasdaq Composite's October high.
In plain words: defensive sectors sell things households buy whether the economy is strong or weak, such as food, soap and medicine. Their revenues move in a narrower range than those of a fast-growing technology company, so their share prices tend to be judged on earnings that are easier to predict. When investors grow unsure about a richly valued sector, that steadiness is what they are paying for.
What the reports attribute the move to
Schroders analysts, quoted by City A.M., put the shift down to growing doubt about technology valuations and about how the enormous AI build-out will be funded over the long term. The same note recorded strength in energy, consumer staples and healthcare worldwide while technology was repriced.
City A.M. also links the timing to the US midterm elections, in which the Democrats took control of the Senate and the House. The report says the result fed concern about the pace of future data-center construction and was followed by a sharp sell-off in AI-linked shares.
CNBC, writing on 11 November, described technology stocks losing momentum while defensive sectors gained, with investors reassessing risk and markets in what it called a "state of alert".
None of the reports I read puts a figure on how much money actually changed hands between the sectors, and neither outlet dates the end of the rotation. The index moves above are what is confirmed; the explanations around them are attributed views, not measurements.
