New$10 Sign Up Bonus & $30 Free Trial Reward
Start challenge

Mental accounting

Treating money differently depending on the purpose or 'account' it is assigned to, instead of treating all money as interchangeable. A related habit is judging each investment on its own rather than as part of the whole portfolio.

Reading
2 min
Sources
4RegulatorResearchCentral bank
Updated
On this page· 5 sections
  1. How it works
  2. Example
  3. Watch out
  4. Sources
  5. Related terms

A dollar is a dollar wherever it came from. Economists call that fungibility, and people often act against it: gift money gets spent more easily than wages, and a tax refund feels like a bonus rather than money that was theirs all along[4].

Mental accounting is the habit behind it. Money gets sorted into labeled pots, and each pot gets its own rules[1].

How it works

The Financial Conduct Authority describes two related habits[1]:

  • Mental accounting: treating money differently according to the purpose assigned to it, although money in a “holiday” account is the same as money in a day-to-day one[1].
  • Narrow bracketing: taking decisions one at a time, without joining them up with other decisions that affect overall wealth and risk, for example making investment choices asset by asset rather than for the whole portfolio[1].

Richard Thaler built the idea into a model of consumer behavior in 1985[2]. It codes combinations of gains and losses with the value function from prospect theory, adds “transaction utility” for how a purchase is judged, and includes the household budgeting process[2].

The label on an account can change a decision. In a 1981 study by Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, people imagined arriving at a theater for a $10 play[3]:

  • having lost a $10 bill on the way, 88% of 183 respondents would still buy a ticket[3];
  • having lost a $10 ticket bought earlier, only 46% of 200 respondents would buy another[3].

The loss is $10 either way. The authors explain the gap by accounts: a second ticket is booked against the theater account, where the play now costs $20, while a lost bill is not tied to the ticket at all[3].

Example

Say a trader keeps $5,000 in a trading account and also owes $5,000 on a credit card that charges 20% a year.

  1. Seen as two pots, the trading money is for trading and the debt is a separate problem.
  2. Seen as one household, the card costs 0.20 × $5,000 = $1,000 a year.
  3. For the trading account to merely cover that cost, it has to earn 20% a year on $5,000.

This is the FCA’s example of saving at a low rate while borrowing at a high one[1], with a trading account in place of savings.

Watch out

Labels are not always a mistake. The FCA notes that people use mental accounts to make decisions more manageable[1], and Thaler’s model counts the household budget as part of mental accounting[2].

Judging positions one by one hides the total. Taking investment decisions separately can expose people to an inappropriate level of overall risk[1].

Windfalls get looser rules. Money that feels extra, such as a refund or a gift, tends to be spent more freely than regular income[4]. A quick trading gain can feel like the same kind of money.

All terms in Tronexopedia

Your challenge starts here

Start your challengeFree TrialNew
Registration bonus

Get $10 free in your Wallet when you sign up

Register and use your $10 Wallet credit to reduce the price of your first challenge.

The $10 bonus is credited to your personal Wallet and can only be used to reduce the price of a challenge purchase. Credits cannot be withdrawn or used for payouts.

Start now & get $10